Yes, an application for a subclass 186 visa can be refused by the Australian Department of Home Affairs if the applicant or sponsoring employer does not meet the relevant immigration requirements. This permanent residency pathway is designed for skilled workers who have been nominated by an eligible Australian employer. Although it offers an opportunity to live and work in Australia indefinitely, approval is not automatic. 
Understanding why refusals happen is important for anyone planning to apply. Applicants must meet the requirements of their chosen stream, provide accurate information, submit suitable supporting documents, and satisfy applicable health, character, and other visa criteria. Problems with the employer's nomination can also affect the outcome.
In this comprehensive guide, we will explain the most common reasons a subclass 186 visa application may be refused, how the nomination process affects the decision, what applicants can do to reduce the risk of rejection, and what options may be available after a refusal.
The key is preparation. Identifying possible problems before submitting an application can help applicants avoid unnecessary delays, additional costs, and complications with their Australian immigration history.
The Australian Employer Nomination Scheme
The Employer Nomination Scheme visa, commonly known as the subclass 186 visa, allows eligible skilled workers to become permanent residents of Australia through employer sponsorship. Applicants generally need an Australian employer to nominate them for an eligible position and must satisfy the requirements of the relevant stream.
There are three main streams:
-
Direct Entry stream: Generally intended for skilled workers who meet the applicable occupation, work experience, skills assessment, English language, and other requirements.
-
Temporary Residence Transition stream: Designed for eligible sponsored workers who meet the applicable employment and visa history requirements.
-
Labour Agreement stream: Available to eligible workers nominated by an employer operating under an applicable labour agreement.
The exact requirements vary by stream and individual circumstances. Applicants should therefore check the official Department of Home Affairs guidance before applying.
A strong application must demonstrate that both the employer and the applicant satisfy the relevant legal requirements. Even if a worker has considerable experience, the application can still be refused if an essential criterion is not met.
Common Reasons a Subclass 186 Visa Application May Be Refused
There is no single reason behind every refusal. The Department assesses the individual application, the employer's nomination, and the relevant legal criteria. The following issues are among the most important to check before applying.
1. The Applicant Does Not Meet the Skills Requirements
Applicants must demonstrate that they have the skills, qualifications, and professional background required under their chosen stream.
For example, a Direct Entry applicant may need a positive skills assessment from the relevant assessing authority. If the assessment is unsuitable, invalid, or does not support the nominated occupation, the application may face difficulties.
The applicant's actual duties should also align with the occupation being nominated. A job title alone is not enough to establish that someone meets the requirements.
How to reduce this risk: Check the occupation requirements, obtain the appropriate skills assessment where required, and ensure that employment references accurately describe your duties, responsibilities, and experience.
2. The Applicant Does Not Have Enough Relevant Work Experience
Work experience is particularly important for the Direct Entry stream. Most applicants need at least three years of relevant work experience unless an applicable exemption applies.
The Temporary Residence Transition stream has different requirements relating to eligible sponsored employment and work history. Applicants must check the rules that apply to their circumstances rather than assuming that experience gained in any job will count.
Problems can arise when employment dates are unclear, duties are unrelated to the nominated occupation, or supporting documents do not establish the required period of work.
How to reduce this risk: Collect employment references, contracts, payslips, tax records, and other reliable evidence. Ensure that dates and job duties are consistent across all documents.
3. The Applicant Is Too Old and Does Not Qualify for an Exemption
The age requirement is another important consideration. For the Direct Entry stream, applicants generally must be under 45 when they apply, unless a specified exemption applies. Other streams also have age criteria and potentially different exemptions.
Some applicants may qualify for an exemption because of their occupation, employment history, or other circumstances defined by immigration law. However, an exemption should never be assumed simply because an employer wants to sponsor a worker.
How to reduce this risk: Check your age against the rules for your specific stream before lodging an application. If you rely on an exemption, confirm that every relevant condition is satisfied and provide evidence to support it.
4. The Employer's Nomination Is Refused
A successful application depends on an eligible employer nomination. The Department must approve the nomination before it can grant the visa.
The nomination may encounter problems if the business is not actively and lawfully operating, the position does not satisfy the applicable requirements, or the employer cannot demonstrate that the proposed employment is genuine.
Other concerns may include the position no longer being available, withdrawal of the nomination, or relevant adverse information about the employer.
An applicant may be fully qualified for a job but still be unable to obtain the visa if the nomination fails.
How to reduce this risk: Work with the employer to ensure the nomination is properly prepared. The business should maintain appropriate records of its operations, the position, the proposed employment arrangements, and the relevant remuneration.
5. Salary or Employment Conditions Do Not Meet the Requirements
The nominated position must satisfy the applicable salary and employment rules. The salary should be assessed against the relevant income threshold and Australian market salary requirements, where applicable.
A salary that looks attractive to the applicant may still fail to meet the legal requirements. Similarly, a job offer with unclear hours, duties, or employment conditions may raise concerns about whether the arrangement satisfies the nomination criteria.
The relevant thresholds can change, so applicants and employers should check the rules applying to the nomination at the time of lodgement.
How to reduce this risk: Ensure that the employment contract, salary records, position description, and nomination information agree with one another. Avoid relying on outdated salary figures or informal promises from an employer.
6. English Language Requirements Are Not Met
English language requirements depend on the stream and any applicable exemption. Direct Entry applicants generally need at least competent English, while other circumstances may be governed by different provisions.
An applicant may face problems if their test results do not meet the required standard, the results are not acceptable under the applicable rules, or the applicant assumes that a qualification automatically provides an exemption.
Family members included in an application may also have requirements relating to English proficiency or an additional visa charge, depending on their circumstances.
How to reduce this risk: Confirm the accepted evidence and applicable English requirements before lodging. If a test is necessary, allow enough time to obtain valid results and check that they satisfy the relevant rules.
7. Health Requirements Are Not Satisfied
Applicants and relevant family members must satisfy the applicable health requirements. The Department may request medical examinations or additional health information before making a decision.
A health issue does not automatically mean that an application will be refused. The outcome depends on the applicable health criteria and the individual circumstances.
Problems can occur when medical examinations are not completed, requested information is missing, or an applicant does not follow the Department's instructions.
How to reduce this risk: Complete the required health checks when instructed, respond to requests within the specified time, and provide accurate medical information. If a complex health issue arises, seek qualified advice about how the relevant criteria apply.
8. Character Concerns or Criminal History
Applicants must meet the applicable character requirements. Criminal convictions, certain past conduct, and other relevant information may affect the assessment.
The Department may examine the nature of an offence, the circumstances surrounding it, and other information relevant under Australian immigration law. A previous conviction does not necessarily produce the same result in every case.
Failing to disclose a relevant matter can create additional problems, particularly if the Department later discovers information that conflicts with the application.
How to reduce this risk: Answer character questions truthfully and provide the requested records. If you have a criminal history or a previous visa cancellation, obtain professional advice before lodging your application.
9. False, Misleading, or Inconsistent Information
Accuracy is essential throughout the visa process. Incorrect employment dates, unsupported qualifications, misleading job descriptions, or inconsistent personal details can undermine an application.
Some errors are accidental. Others may raise concerns about whether information was deliberately misrepresented. The legal consequences depend on the circumstances and the relevant provisions.
For instance, an employment reference may state that a worker performed managerial duties, while other records indicate that the worker carried out a substantially different role. The Department may request an explanation or further evidence.
How to reduce this risk: Review every form and supporting document before submission. Disclose relevant information, correct mistakes promptly, and do not alter records to make your experience appear more suitable.
10. Previous Visa Refusals or Cancellations
A previous visa refusal or cancellation can affect a new application, depending on the circumstances. It does not automatically mean that every future application will be refused, but the applicant's immigration history must be considered.
Certain previous decisions may create legal restrictions or additional issues that must be resolved before a new application can be lodged or granted.
How to reduce this risk: Keep copies of earlier decisions and review the reasons for any refusal or cancellation. Determine whether the earlier matter affects your eligibility, whether any restrictions apply, and what evidence may be needed to address the concern.
How to Prepare a Stronger Application
A carefully prepared application can help reduce avoidable problems. Although no preparation can guarantee approval, applicants can take practical steps to demonstrate that they meet the relevant requirements.
Review the Requirements for Your Stream
Start by identifying whether you are applying through Direct Entry, Temporary Residence Transition, or Labour Agreement. Each stream has distinct eligibility requirements.
Do not rely entirely on another person's experience. A friend may have qualified under a different stream, benefited from an exemption, or applied under rules that have since changed.
Review the official requirements and confirm how they apply to your circumstances before making commitments to an employer.
Organise Your Supporting Documents
Prepare a clear set of documents that supports your claims. Depending on your circumstances, these may include:
-
Passport and identity documents.
-
Qualifications and relevant skills assessment.
-
Employment references and work history.
-
English language evidence, where required.
-
Employer nomination and employment contract information.
-
Health and character documents, as requested.
-
Evidence relating to any applicable exemption.
-
Documents for eligible family members included in the application.
The precise list will vary. Submitting large numbers of irrelevant documents is not a substitute for providing the evidence that directly addresses the legal requirements.
Check the Employer's Eligibility
The employer should understand its responsibilities and ensure the nomination meets the relevant criteria.
Before lodging, confirm that the business is operating lawfully, the position is available, and the proposed employment arrangements are consistent with the nomination. The employer should also ensure that its supporting documents are accurate and complete.
Good communication between the employer and applicant can help prevent discrepancies between the nomination and the visa application.
Check Every Detail Before Lodgement
Small mistakes can cause unnecessary complications. Review names, dates, job titles, employment periods, salary details, and other important information carefully.
If you discover an error after submission, do not ignore it. Follow the Department's instructions for notifying it of incorrect information and providing any necessary correction.
Applicants should also monitor their ImmiAccount and respond to requests for information within the stated deadlines.
What Happens If a Subclass 186 Visa Is Refused?
Receiving a refusal can be stressful, especially after spending time and money preparing an application. However, the next step should be based on the reasons for the decision rather than an immediate assumption that the process is over.
Read the Refusal Letter Carefully
The Department will notify you of its decision in writing and explain the reasons for refusal. The notice should also indicate whether the decision can be reviewed.
Read the letter carefully to identify which requirements were not satisfied. For example, the problem may relate to the employer's nomination, your work experience, your age, or another eligibility criterion.
Understanding the precise issue helps you decide whether to seek a review, consider another application, or explore another lawful migration pathway.
Consider Whether a Review Is Available
Some visa and nomination decisions may be reviewable by the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART). However, review rights depend on the type of decision, the applicant's circumstances, and the applicable law.
Time limits can be strict. Check the refusal notice immediately and obtain qualified advice about eligibility and deadlines. Do not assume that every refusal can be reviewed or that a review will automatically allow you to remain in Australia.
Consider a New Application
In some cases, a fresh application may be worth considering after the underlying problem has been addressed. For example, an applicant may need to obtain appropriate evidence, correct an issue with the nomination, or establish eligibility under a different pathway.
However, lodging again is not always the best solution. A previous refusal may affect eligibility, and age limits, work history, visa conditions, or other requirements may change over time.
The application fee is generally not refunded simply because the Department refuses the visa. Applicants should therefore assess their options carefully before paying for another application.
Can an Approved Employer Nomination Still Lead to Refusal?
Yes. Approval of the employer's nomination does not guarantee that the worker's visa application will succeed.
The nomination and visa application involve related but distinct requirements. Even after the nomination is approved, the applicant must satisfy the applicable visa criteria.
For example, the employer may have demonstrated that a genuine position is available, but the applicant may not meet a required age criterion or may have an unresolved issue relating to English proficiency.
This is why applicants should check their personal eligibility separately from the employer's eligibility. Both parts of the process matter, and approval of one does not remove the requirements of the other.
Conclusion
Yes, a subclass 186 visa can be refused if the applicant or sponsoring employer fails to satisfy the applicable immigration requirements. Common reasons include insufficient work experience, an unsuitable skills assessment, failure to meet age or English language requirements, nomination problems, health or character concerns, and inaccurate information.
The most effective way to reduce refusal risks is to understand the requirements of your chosen stream, prepare reliable supporting documents, and ensure that your employer's nomination and your personal application are consistent. Applicants should also check current rules because eligibility requirements and income thresholds can change.
If your application has already been refused, read the decision carefully and determine whether a review or another lawful pathway is available. Act promptly because deadlines may apply, and do not assume that a new application will automatically resolve the problem.
With careful preparation and an accurate understanding of the relevant rules, applicants can make more informed decisions and avoid many preventable mistakes. Because every case is different, complex situations should be assessed by a qualified Australian migration professional using the current legislation and the details of the individual application.